Friday, May 21, 2010
Franklin Hall B Level 4 (Philadelphia Marriott Downtown)
11:00 AM
A. Ard ,
University of Portland, Portland, OR
M. LaMadrid ,
Sound Choice Pharmaceutical Institute,
Seattle, WA
S. Bwabye ,
Sound Choice Pharmaceutical Institute, Seattle, WA
K. Koyama ,
Sound Choice Pharmaceutical Institute, Seattle, WA
T. Deisher ,
Sound Choice Pharmaceutical Institute, Seattle, WA
Background: Autism prevalence rates in the US and UK began
increasing temporally close to the time that the MMR vaccine was
switched from the type manufactured using animal cells to a type
manufactured using human cells. A yet unstudied possible
environmental cause for autism is residual human DNA contaminant in
the vaccines produced using human cells. Debate about the dangers
of residual human DNA in vaccines has been going on for 50 years,
mainly related to cancer initiation. Clinical gene therapy (1996)
of male infants has induced childhood leukemia due to improper DNA
insertion. To minimize the possibility of oncogenic DNA
integrating into a vaccine recipient’s genome, the WHO and FDA have
recommended DNAse treatments to reduce the size of contaminant DNA
fragments to less than genic lengths, ~200-1000bp. These
recommendations were developed before the sequencing of the human
genome. DNA cellular diffusion studies have shown that short DNA
fragments (<250bp) have higher probability of entering the nucleus
than longer lengths. Gene therapy studies have also demonstrated
that naked DNA, injected intramuscularly, can remain intact and be
transported to the brain via retrograde axonal transport in motor
neurons. Once inside the nucleus, exogenous DNA can integrate via
homologous recombination, potentially in genomic regions called
‘recombination hotspots’. Intra-species DNA integration, e.g., by
homologous recombination, occurs with a probability a billion times
greater than inter-species homologous recombination. Integration
of short human DNA fragments has the potential to contribute to
various human diseases, including autism.
Objectives: To verify the lengths of residual human DNA in
vaccines and to determine if recombination hotspots occur near or in
X-chromosome genes known to be associated with autism.
Methods: Human DNA from inactivated vaccines was isolated and
characterized using standard procedures. A list of recombination
hotspots, computationally derived by using Hapmap Phase II data, was
downloaded. A list of 238 genes associated with autism (AAGs) was
downloaded from the ACGMAP website. Gene coordinates, including
transcription start and end sites, were downloaded from the UCSC
Human Genome website. Software was written to automate the
location of overlaps between autism associated genes and
recombination hotspots.
Results: The average human DNA fragment length in rubella vaccine
was 220 base pairs. Out of 1145 hotspots in the X-chromosome, 25
hotspots are located in 5 of 15 X-chromosome AAGs, between the
transcription start and end sites. These genes are NLGN3 and
NLGN4X (neuroligins involved in synapse formation), AFF2 and
IL1RAPL1 (involved in X-linked mental retardation), and GRPR (gastrin
releasing peptide receptor).
Conclusions: Autism-associated genes in the X-chromosome contain
multiple regions where potential insertion of short, non-host
homologous DNA can occur. With new knowledge due to the human genome
project, particularly in regards to SNPs and epigenetics, further
work must be done to understand the implications of integrated
residual human DNA to the etiology of autism.